Eisenkot takes the mandate, but the math offers no easy escape

By Tom Beckwith · Reporting from Washington ·

President Isaac Herzog handed Gadi Eisenkot the mandate after Benjamin Netanyahu lost his majority, but unyielding parliamentary arithmetic makes any anti-Netanyahu coalition as fragile as the order it replaces.

Interests first: the arithmetic of a broken majority

Read a diplomatic cable from the bottom up. You look at the raw numbers before you listen to the speeches. In the October election, Benjamin Netanyahu’s religious-nationalist coalition dropped to 53 seats, as reported by The Guardian. That leaves the long-serving prime minister short of the simple majority required to govern. Across the aisle, Gadi Eisenkot’s opposition bloc secured 48 seats. The numbers do not lie. Netanyahu’s camp cannot reach a majority without breaking its internal discipline or forging unnatural alliances.

This is not a failure of persuasion; it is a failure of addition. Netanyahu faces an active criminal indictment and has lashed out on video, claiming the vote was stolen through foreign funding and bribery. He warned that any minority government backed by Arab parties means Israel will "simply not survive," as noted by CNN. But the math is stubborn. When President Isaac Herzog held consultations with every party in the incoming Knesset, Eisenkot secured the recommendations of 67 lawmakers, including endorsements from Arab parties, according to CNN. Netanyahu managed only 46 recommendations, with United Torah Judaism declining to back him.

What does each capital fear most? Netanyahu fears the loss of executive immunity and the dismantling of his political apparatus. Eisenkot fears a caretaker prime minister operating the security and law enforcement systems after losing the confidence of the electorate. As Eisenkot wrote on X, "A situation in which a caretaker prime minister in the minority... continues to operate the security system and law enforcement authorities, is a dangerous situation that must not continue even for one more day." The 2021 Israeli legislative election offers the clear parallel: a disparate, anti-Netanyahu coalition assembling centrist and Arab parties to break a grinding political deadlock through sheer institutional exhaustion. The shared mechanism here is the tactical must-win union of bitter rivals who agree on only one baseline fact—that the incumbent's continued hold on power is a structural threat to the state.

Capabilities: the hard hand of a former chief of staff

To understand what Eisenkot can actually do, you look at his resume, not his campaign slogans. The former military chief of staff brings the cold calculations of a man who commanded during the 2006 Lebanon war and devised the Dahiya doctrine of massive force against infrastructure, as detailed by The Guardian. He is the son of Moroccan immigrants and could become the first prime minister from the Mizrahi community, according to the Khaleej Times. He broke from Benny Gantz’s National Unity party in July 2025 to found Yashar, positioning himself specifically to capture security-minded voters who are utterly exhausted by Netanyahu's permanent state of crisis.

Yet his capabilities are boxed in by mutual vetoes. Avigdor Liberman, leader of Yisrael Beiteinu, has ruled out any government dependent on Arab parties, writing on X that such a path is a "short road to annihilation," as reported by CNN. Liberman demands a 61-lawmaker coalition excluding Arab lists while predicting defections from Likud. Eisenkot, meanwhile, has set conditions for joining any administration: recognizing Israel as a Jewish, democratic, liberal, and egalitarian state; committing to the Declaration of Independence; universal service; and recognizing Hamas as a terrorist organization, according to CNN.

The strongest opposing case for Netanyahu's survival rests on the argument that no centrist coalition can bridge the chasm between Zionist hawks like Liberman and Arab-majority list endorsers without collapsing under its own ideological weight. The best evidence for this view is the sheer ideological distance between Arab lawmakers who reject Zionism and former IDF generals who enforce it. But this defense defeats itself. It assumes Netanyahu's right-wing bloc possesses a cohesion it has already lost. The religious-nationalist alliance is splintering over draft exemptions for ultra-Orthodox men—a flashpoint where the opposition pledged universal service while Haredi parties demand blanket exemptions, as CNN notes. If the ultra-Orthodox draft dispute breaks the religious-nationalist alliance, Liberman's veto is the only thing standing between Eisenkot and a working majority.

Statements last: the cost five years out

Statements are the noise in the wire copy; capabilities and interests are the signal. Netanyahu has pitched a broad national unity government under his own leadership, calling for all Zionist parties to preserve the state, while Eisenkot dismissed this message as a "pathetic spin," according to CNN and KTVU. Yashar's official position is clear. If Likud wants a broad unity government, it must dissolve its alliance with extremists and enter a government under Prime Minister Eisenkot, as reported by CNN.

Price this move five years out. The ledger looks sobering. If Eisenkot fails to forge a coalition within his initial 28-day window—with a possible 14-day extension from President Herzog, as noted by DW and the Khaleej Times—the mandate reverts to Netanyahu, dragging the country toward yet another election. But if Eisenkot succeeds by building a minority government or engineering defections from moderate Likud lawmakers eager to avoid electoral wipeout, the cost is a fragile administration perpetually held hostage by its external Arab-list supporters and internal right-wing hawks.

The president has made his choice, handing the mandate to a soldier who knows how to break a stalemate with calculated force rather than diplomatic platitudes. Eisenkot must assemble a Cabinet, negotiate budgets, and face a new Knesset being sworn in on Tuesday, according to CNN. If the opposition succeeds in replacing Netanyahu's Knesset speaker and establishing a state commission of inquiry into the security failures of October 7, the political architecture of the last decade will collapse into history. The era of permanent Netanyahu rule is not ended by a sudden conversion of the electorate; it is ended by the unyielding arithmetic of a nation that simply ran out of patience.

Sources

  1. The Guardian: Israel’s president picks Yashar leader Gadi Eisenkot to form government
  2. CNN: In setback to Netanyahu, rival Eisenkot to be tasked with forming next Israeli government. But the path remains complicated
  3. KTVU: Netanyahu opponent Gadi Eisenkot picked to form Israeli government
  4. DW: Israeli president picks Gadi Eisenkot to form government
  5. Khaleej Times: Israeli president picks Gadi Eisenkot, Netanyahu's rival, to form government