Ueno Bank looted Paraguay's workers, and Santiago Peña must pay
By Maya Ellison · Reporting from Detroit ·
When the collapse of Ueno Bank froze three million accounts and toppled Santiago Peña, it exposed how elite plunder robs workers who must now be repaid in full.
The digital trap that locked three million people out of their lives Nearly three million Paraguayans learned on a Monday night that their money had vanished into thin air. The central bank ordered Ueno Bank into resolution due to insolvency, as reported by The Guardian. The digital lender had aggressively courted the unbanked and the poor with supermarket rebates and slick apps. Pedro Volpe, a writer and lawyer, told The Guardian it was very easy to open an account. Now he is working miracles to pay bills while basic food items are out of reach for many. That digital convenience was a trapdoor.
Overnight, 60% of the adult population found their bank accounts frozen. They were left unable to buy food, pay rent, or move through daily life. As BBC reports, long lines of frantic depositors formed at Ueno branches in Asunción on Tuesday and Wednesday. They pleaded for access to life savings and pensions. The central bank seized the lender, but the damage was already done. Thousands of people protested in the streets on Thursday to demand their money back. Police met demonstrators with tear gas and water cannons, according to BBC. When the digital ledger of a nation is built on quicksand, it is the people at the bottom who sink first.
A web of insider plunder disguised as market innovation This was never a mere accident of the market; it was a heist engineered from the top down. As Al Jazeera notes, right-wing President Santiago Peña is a former International Monetary Fund economist. Peña appointed Carlos Carvallo Spalding, the former CEO of Ueno's predecessor company, to head the Central Bank of Paraguay, according to DW. Less than three months later, Spalding authorized Ueno to become a digital bank, as detailed by The Guardian. Peña himself held shares in the company that became Ueno Holding. Investigators later found that Ueno loaned $146m to companies tied to its owner, Grupo Vázquez, exceeding legal limits with insufficient collateral, as reported by Al Jazeera.
This is the exact machinery of the Baninter collapse in the Dominican Republic, driven by massive internal fraud. Peña dismissed internal central bank reports of irregularities as a false media campaign, exactly as elites do when caught with their hands in the cookie jar. But the books did not lie once regularized: Ueno had less than half the solvency required to meet its obligations. Here, the speed of a digital app masked the plunder of a nation's public trust.
The bank held roughly $800m in public-sector deposits, including money from hydroelectric dam operators and state pension funds, according to DW. Approximately 32,000 pensioners were left without payments because their public pension funds were invested in Ueno Bank. Meanwhile, 300 media workers had their salaries suspended after operations halted at radio stations and newspapers belonging to the same financial group, as reported by The Guardian.
The swift fall of a puppet and the permanent price of impunity The political reckoning was swift, but it was designed to protect the architects of the plunder. As France 24 details, historian and political analyst Fabián Chamorro observed that protests were growing every day. Peña's impeachment was the way Congress found to prevent a popular explosion. On Thursday, Peña offered to resign in an attempt to retain a life senatorship under the constitution. Lawmakers stripped him of the seat regardless, voting overwhelmingly to impeach him for misconduct, conflicts of interest, and diverted pension funds, according to BBC. Senators impeached Peña and placed him under house arrest on Friday, ensuring he lost the immunity usually granted to ex-presidents, as reported by BBC. Pedro Alliana, Peña's deputy, was sworn in as interim president, promising that compatriots going through a difficult time would be fully compensated, according to BBC.
Yet as Yinal López, a worker at the state electricity company whose pension fund was trapped at Ueno, told France 24, this was an enormous betrayal of trust. The president made a mockery of the people. Police arrested eight senior executives and directors, including founder Miguel Vázquez who was held at Tacumbú prison. Prosecutors charged 27 people with breach of trust and attempted fraud. The political apparatus of the Colorado Party—which has ruled Paraguay almost uninterrupted, as Al Jazeera reminds us—seeks to wash its hands of its own creation. Defense lawyer Ricardo Preda called the allegations a reckless accusation. But the millions of workers standing outside locked bank doors know the truth written in their empty pockets.
Justice would require that every gourani stolen from public pension funds and ordinary savings accounts be returned immediately through confiscated elite assets and windfall taxes on the financial class, rather than deferred promises or austerity. Santiago Peña, Carlos Carvallo Spalding, and the network of political patrons who traded public oversight for private enrichment must face full criminal accountability without the shield of legislative immunity or party protection.
Sources
- The Guardian: ‘Very strange, very sad’: Paraguay bank collapse fells a presidency and leaves millions broke
- BBC: Paraguay's President Santiago Peña impeached and under house arrest
- Al Jazeera: How Paraguay’s Ueno collapse is only its latest banking crisis
- DW: Paraguay: President Santiago Pena under house arrest over bank crisis
- BBC: Paraguay's president impeached and under house arrest after bank collapse
- France 24: Paraguay places ousted president Peña under house arrest after bank collapse