Uncalled races in Mississippi and Alaska expose political fantasy

By Dana Whitfield · Reporting from Washington ·

As uncounted ballots stall Senate calls in Mississippi and Alaska, partisan posturing gives way to the unforgiving arithmetic of institutional election rules.

Provisional ballots and the stubborn arithmetic of the Mississippi ledger

We live in an age of elective reality. Partisans treat vote tallies like subscription services. If you do not like what is playing, you change the channel. But mathematics is a stubborn creditor. Control of the House and the Senate is already decided. As the Guardian reports, Democrats will hold a strong majority in the upcoming Congress. Yet the national conversation remains transfixed by the uncalled contests in Mississippi and Alaska. In both states, the arithmetic refuses to yield to partisan prayers.

Consider the Mississippi Senate race. Democratic challenger Scott Colom leads Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith by a little over 1,100 votes, according to AP News. This is no sudden tremor. It continues an institutional clash that turned personal in 2023. In that year, Senator Hyde-Smith refused to return her blue slip, blocking Colom's federal judicial nomination. Now, Mississippi counts provisional and affidavit ballots ahead of the November 10 deadline. The state lacks an automatic recount mechanism. That throws the full weight of governance onto raw paper.

The strongest opposing case comes from the state Republican apparatus. Mississippi Republican Party Chair Mike Hurst insists his side built an operation ready before the fight began. He stated to NBC News that every outstanding ballot, county, and legal option will get their full attention. He expressed firm conviction that Hyde-Smith will be re-elected if the law is followed. This is the sound of institutional discipline. On its own terms, it has merit. But it ignores the structural reality of the 2018 United States Senate election in Mississippi, where an incumbent Republican was re-elected to a second full term. Grit and legal vigilance cannot manufacture uncast votes. They can only audit the existing ledger. When the ledger depends on provisional envelopes, hope is not a strategy.

The ranked-choice reckoning in the last frontier

Far to the north, Alaska offers a different lesson in institutional machinery. It shows what happens when a state designs a voting system to prevent plurality rule from bypassing the broader electorate. NBC News reports that Democrat Mary Peltola leads incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan by just over 600 votes with ballots remaining. Neither candidate has cleared the 50 percent threshold required to avoid Alaska's ranked-choice tabulation.

Here, both political camps have indulged in fantasies that defy the state's election code. On one side, allegations surfaced in The New York Times that Democrats recruited an independent candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. They allegedly sought to siphon votes from the incumbent. That is a clumsy dirty trick if true, though Peltola has denied any knowledge of it. On the other side, the Trump administration filed a federal lawsuit to block election results. They aimed to pause certification if the incumbent loses by a small margin due to same-name confusion. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason wisely dismissed that lawsuit on November 1.

Partisans want you to believe that narrative momentum or preemptive litigation wins elections. They are wrong. Preference transfers and statutory thresholds win elections. As Lakshya Jain of Split Ticket noted on social media, Sullivan faces a difficult position given what remains in the stack. When second-preference votes are redistributed later this month under Alaska's ranked-choice rules, the math will settle the matter. Federal lawsuits seeking a shortcut around the ballot box will not change that.

California dreams and the price of fiscal fantasy

Nowhere is the collision between partisan delusion and fiscal reality sharper than in California Proposition 40. The measure proposes a one-time 5 percent tax on the net worth of the state's roughly 200 billionaires. Proponents claim it would raise money for health care and education. It is a classic piece of populist engineering: promise a free lunch and ignore capital flight. Unsurprisingly, as the BBC reports, one million more people voted against the measure than in favor. It even drew opposition from Governor Gavin Newsom.

Voters are not always romantic. They are pragmatic when confronted with ledger-book absurdities. The progressive left wanted a magical windfall to fund social priorities without trade-offs. The anti-tax right pretends that state balance sheets manage themselves through pure grit. Both camps are selling fairy tales. Looking at the mechanics of state taxation, California voters drew the line.

We must stop treating elections and ballot measures as moral pageants where emotional appeal wins the prize. Whether Scott Colom tests Mississippi's affidavit ballot deadlines, Mary Peltola navigates Alaska's ranked-choice redistribution, or voters reject wealth taxes, the demand is identical. Respect the institutional architecture, do the arithmetic, and live with the result. Counting every legal vote without whining about the rules is all that protects a functioning republic from a constitutional crisis.

Sources

  1. BBC: Boebert, billionaires' tax and other midterms races still to watch
  2. NPR: These are the races in the House and Senate that haven't been called yet
  3. NBC News: Election 2026 results live updates: Vote tallies in Alaska, Mississippi and Kansas continue after Democratic sweep
  4. AP News: What races the AP has not yet called in contests for Senate and governor
  5. Politico: The races we're still waiting on ...
  6. The Guardian: US elections 2026 live: Democrats exceed 250 House seats as blue wave sweeping Congress grows