Pete Hegseth must resign or face a constitutional check

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

Facing articles of impeachment, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth dismissed legislative oversight as a sham, confusing cable rhetoric with constitutional procedure.

The holding and the heat

When an executive official facing removal takes to a screen to declare the process a sham, he misunderstands the instrument held against him. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth released a video on Thursday stating, "We Stand, We Fight." He filmed it beneath a sign reading "Department of War," as reported by CNN. He dismissed the impending articles of impeachment from Representative Thomas Massie, a Republican from Kentucky. He called them the work of a "disgruntled, defeated congressman, along with all his Democrat allies," according to NBC News. Massie lost his primary. He announced plans to reintroduce the resolution when the House returns to Washington on Monday. He noted that his resolution is a "much gentler version of what's coming when Dem's control Congress." Massie wrote on X that "there is one contingency in which I won't reintroduce the articles of impeachment: Hegseth resigns." Hegseth invoked the 2024 assassination attempt on President Donald Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania, instead of weighing the institutional gravity of the charge. "He literally took a bullet for this nation," Hegseth stated. "He shook his fist and said 'fight, fight, fight,' and so will we." This is not legal reasoning. It is the rhetoric of a cable broadcast transposed onto the machinery of state.

The strongest opposing case for Hegseth's posture holds that an official targeted by a hostile legislature owes his loyalty to the executive who appointed him. He does not owe it to the parliamentary comfort of his critics. Buckling to calls for a firing rewards congressional overreach. In this view, the war in Iran has lasted eight months, according to DW. The resulting midterm losses gave Democrats control of Congress by large margins. Those losses should not compromise the civilian leadership of the Pentagon. President Trump told reporters that Hegseth was doing a "fantastic job," praising the U.S. raid in Venezuela to extract then-dictator Nicolás Maduro. Speaking in the Oval Office, Trump added: "we had so many generals. Everybody was a four-star general. I never saw anything like it. And many of those people were woke. I don't like a woke general. And so, he probably has opposition." Chief Pentagon spokesman Sean Parnell echoed this defense. He stated that Hegseth "will not back down or be deterred by politicians seeking to score partisan points or launch phony investigations where no wrongdoing exists."

The defense collapses because it confuses the score with the process. The question is not whether the secretary shares the president's populist animus against military leadership. It is not whether the purge of admirals and generals pleased the base. The question is whether an unrepentant refusal to engage with the legislative branch can survive the day the other side holds the tool. That refusal touches troop casualties, damage to U.S. bases in the Middle East, and war strategy. If a cabinet officer can stonewall Congress on war strategy and survive by cutting social media videos invoking the politics of personal destruction, congressional oversight becomes a prop. Democratic Sen. Ruben Gallego told CNN's Jake Tapper: "You're conducting a war right now, and then you're reacting as if you're on Fox News. It's ridiculous. … If he wanted to make a good argument for him not to be impeached, he literally just doubled down and asked for an impeachment." Moving from a studio desk to the Department of War requires an understanding that procedure is not a suggestion.

The parallel of the first impeachment

We have walked this exact road before, down to the choreography of the grievance. During the First impeachment of Donald Trump, the mechanism was identical. An executive official facing accountability framed the proceeding not as a constitutional check, but as a partisan witch hunt driven by personal animus rather than legal merit. The House of Representatives adopted articles of impeachment for abuse of power and obstruction of Congress on December 18, 2019. The defense from the administration and its allies relied entirely on the vocabulary of the sham. That playbook preserved an executive tenure through a Senate acquittal on February 5, 2020. Yet treating institutional oversight as a nullity sets a precedent that cannot be boxed in.

The structural rot goes deeper than the secretary's rhetoric. The midterm debacle was not merely a general election setback. It was a fracture within the ruling party itself. Vice President JD Vance posted on social media Tuesday that the GOP losses were due to the war in Iran. He wrote on X that "the reason we lost is the war" and that "if you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so." The irony is absolute. Vance cast the tie-breaking vote in the Senate to confirm Hegseth as Secretary of Defense, according to historical records. Now, the vice president openly blames that same tenure for the loss of the chamber. Meanwhile, outgoing North Carolina Republican Sen. Thom Tillis told CNN's Kaitlan Collins on Wednesday: "I don't think he has invested enough in the US Senate or Congress to even get a funding request done." He added that "Hegseth is just not the right guy for the job." Tillis previously voted to confirm Hegseth after demanding a sworn statement regarding alcohol and abuse allegations. He later called that confirmatory vote the biggest regret of his career. The administration requests a defense budget of $1.5 trillion while its defense secretary treats the authorizing committees with open contempt. The machinery grinds to a halt not because of Democratic malice, but because the executive has abandoned the work of governing.

Twenty years ago, during the George W. Bush administration, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld was removed from office. That followed midterm election defeats for Republicans during the Iraq war. That historical pattern predicts the current collision. An unpopular Middle Eastern conflict drains the political capital of the ruling party. The defense chief becomes the unavoidable sacrifice. Rumsfeld was a seasoned bureaucrat whose departure was engineered quietly. Hegseth has chosen to wrap himself in the iconography of the MAGA movement. He dares his own party's backbenchers and the incoming Democratic majority to bring the hammer down. Democratic House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries asked on social media Thursday: "Why is Pete Hegseth still around?" Representative Adam Smith, the top Democrat expected to lead the House Armed Services Committee, promised vigorous oversight of the war against Iran.

A cabinet officer who invites an impeachment trial while budget negotiations hang in the balance forgets where power resides. Power resides in the statute, not the reel. Pete Hegseth must resign or be removed. A Department of War cannot be run from a green room. A republic cannot long endure an executive who treats a constitutional check as a television adversary.

Sources

  1. CNN: Hegseth’s ‘fight, fight, fight’ video pours fuel on impeachment flames
  2. NBC News: Pete Hegseth strikes defiant tone in face of impeachment threat
  3. CBC News: Hegseth defends record as Pentagon chief, slams 'sham' push for his impeachment
  4. DW: Pete Hegseth under fire as Republicans trade blame for midterm debacle