Macron's budget cuts are fueling the fire in French schools
By Maya Ellison · Reporting from Detroit ·
Emmanuel Macron is starving French classrooms to balance the budget, sparking a student revolt that the state is meeting with police force instead of funding.
The French government is treating its youth like a line item to be trimmed. They are starving the classrooms to feed the bond markets, and now they are acting shocked that the children are burning the buildings down. This is not a mystery. It is a math problem. When you tell a generation that their future is less important than a fiscal target, you are not managing a budget. You are managing a fuse.
The ledger of abandonment
Follow the money and you will find the fire. CNBC reports that Finance Minister Roland Lescure is targeting a fiscal adjustment worth 54 billion euros. To get there, the government plans to freeze wages for public sector workers. This includes the teachers.
The 2027 budget shows education spending will rise by 1.7%. That is below the rate of inflation. For the students in Paris' poorer suburbs, this is not a statistic. It is a classroom that is too crowded to breathe in. It is a long school day. It is the heat of a summer wave in a building with no cooling.
I know this feeling. I grew up in Flint, Michigan. I watched my city get hollowed out by people in suits who thought "efficiency" was more important than clean water. This is the same Student debt crisis logic that defined my twenties. The state decides that the cost of a future is too high, so it shifts the burden onto the most vulnerable. Then it wonders why the vulnerable are angry.
The state's playbook of blame
The response from the Macron administration has been a masterclass in deflection. Education Minister Édouard Geffray admits the movement was "legitimate at the outset." But as soon as the windows broke, the narrative shifted. Now, the Interior Ministry calls it "urban violence." They claim the France Unbowed Party (LFI) is pulling the strings.
They are using the same script from the 2005 French riots. Back then, the state reframed systemic neglect as criminal behavior. They did it again here. RFI English reports that 5,000 people have been arrested. Roughly 90 percent of those detained were minors.
Instead of fixing the roofs or hiring the missing teachers, Justice Minister Gerald Darmanin wants to make parents pay. He is seeking civil liability against parents for the vandalism. This is a cruel joke. The state fails to maintain the school, the students revolt, and then the state bills the working-class parents for the damage. It is a predatory cycle that mirrors the way Occupy Wall Street was met with batons instead of a conversation about greed.
The lie of the cautionary tale
There are people in the United States watching this and seeing a different story. Tomi Lahren calls this a "cautionary tale" about open borders and diversity. She claims that letting people "leech off of your system" leads to this violence.
That is a lie. The students are not rioting because of where their neighbors were born. They are rioting because their schools are dilapidated. They are rioting because there are no substitute teachers. They are rioting because the government is more worried about a 5.1% deficit than a child's education.
This is not about immigration. This is the 2023 French pension reform protests all over again. The mechanism is identical: the state imposes austerity and budget cuts on the working class to satisfy fiscal targets, triggering mass civil disobedience. Whether it is the retirement age or the classroom ceiling, the trigger is the same. The government decides that the ledger must be balanced on the backs of the people.
The state is now using tear gas and rubber bullets to protect a budget that is killing the public square. They have closed up to 500 schools. They have injured 170 pupils and 65 education staff. They are fighting a war against teenagers to protect the state ledger.
Emmanuel Macron and his ministers are the ones who owe a debt here. They owe the students of France a functional education system. They owe the teachers a wage that keeps up with the cost of bread. Justice would require the government to scrap the wage freezes and invest the 54 billion euros back into the people. Until they do, the fire will not go out. You cannot starve a generation and expect them to be grateful for the crumbs.
Sources
- Fox News: France’s violent student protests raise warning for America: ‘A cautionary tale’
- The Guardian: French education minister says up to 500 schools could remain closed on Monday after student protests – Europe live
- CNBC: A violent classroom revolt is becoming France's next big crisis
- Infobae: Entre 400 y 500 centros educativos prevén cerrar el lunes en Francia por las protestas
- ABC Color: Entre 400 y 500 centros educativos prevén cerrar el lunes en Francia por las protestas
- RFI English: France closes 400 schools as student unrest over conditions continues