By exiling Stolpersteine, Heidenau trades memory for quiet
By Elena Rossi · Reporting from Rome ·
When Heidenau voted to ban new Stolpersteine with conservative help, it attacked the decentralized public memory that protects European democracy from its darkest past.
The pavement belongs to the living
History does not live only in the cold bronze of a national monument. It lives under our boots, in the grit of the sidewalk where a family once walked before the trucks came. The town of Heidenau, sitting quietly near Dresden in Saxony, has decided it prefers a tidier pavement. The municipal council resolved to stop permitting new Stolpersteine on its streets, according to The Jerusalem Post. These are the small ten-centimetre concrete cubes topped with brass plates, initiated by the artist Gunter Demnig in the 1990s, that mark the last known residence or workplace of those the Nazis hunted down and murdered.
To walk past them is to stumble, if only for an instant, over the names of the dead. That is the point. The 116,000 plaques spread across 31 countries refuse to let us look away into the comforting distance of a distant museum. But in Heidenau, the Alternative for Germany and the Christian Democratic Union found common cause. They argued that passersby are walking over or even stepping onto the names of the victims, as reported by cnn.com. They prefer that future commemorations be neatly tucked away out of sight at the northern cemetery. This is not modesty. It is an act of municipal sanitation, an attempt to sweep the inconvenient past into the grass where nobody has to trip over it on the way to the bakery.
The firewall crumbles in the east
We are told by the proponents of this ban that they are sparing the victims the indignity of a pedestrian's sole. But this argument is a transparent alibi for something much uglier. As DW.com notes, the motion was brought by the far-right AfD and the center-right CDU. The AfD has been designated a confirmed right-wing extremist endeavor by domestic intelligence, though that label is currently under review. When a conservative party joins hands with such forces to legislate memory out of the public square, the political firewall—the Brandmauer that has long kept mainstream German democracy distinct from the fringes—begins to resemble a rotting fence.
The strongest opposing case comes from those who argue, much as Munich’s Jewish community and leaders like Charlotte Knobloch have done in the past, that placing names upon the ground where feet tread can risk an echo of past desecration. The Nazi regime itself once paved sidewalks with stolen Jewish gravestones. It is a serious ethical argument, advanced by people of profound moral standing. Yet in Heidenau, that argument is weaponized by politicians who dream of a different curriculum. An AfD official in Saxony-Anhalt recently summarized this revisionist yearning with startling clarity: "more Bismarck – less Hitler." They do not object to the treading; they object to the naming. They wish to restore a public space purged of uncomfortable truths.
The cost of forgetting in the piazza
Gunter Demnig observed that given the recent electoral successes of the AfD, something like this was completely to be expected, as the BBC reported. The electoral winds blowing through Saxony-Anhalt are carrying a cold draft across the old East. When the CDU helps push Nazi victims out of the city center and into the cemetery, as the International Auschwitz Committee observed, they are disposing of them where the far right has always wanted them: out of sight and out of mind. Federal politicians like Green co-leader Felix Banaszak have rightly called it a scandal.
The Stolpersteine project, initiated by the German artist Gunter Demnig in 1992, relies on a ten-centimetre concrete cube bearing a brass plate inscribed with the name and life dates of victims of Nazi extermination or persecution. With 100,000 Stolpersteine laid, it stands as the world's largest decentralized memorial. Its shared mechanism is the use of decentralized, everyday public spaces to integrate the memory of victims into the living fabric of the city. Institutions do not fall in a single afternoon of revolutionary fury; they erode one municipal council vote at a time, through the quiet compromises of men who think they can sup with extremists without catching their fever. To banish memory to the periphery is to signal that the piazza belongs only to the unburdened. If European democracy is to endure, it must find the courage to keep its history right where people walk, stumble, and remember.
Sources
- cnn.com: Outrage as East German town bans Holocaust ‘stumbling blocks’
- BBC: German town bans 'stumbling stone' memorials to Nazi victims
- DW.com: AfD, CDU ban new Holocaust 'stumbling stones' in Heidenau
- The Jerusalem Post: German city votes to end Stolpersteine Holocaust memorial stones for Nazi victims
- BBC: German town bans 'stumbling stone' memorials to Nazi victims