Xi summit with Trump offers truce cover but leaves war intact
By Tom Beckwith · Reporting from Washington ·
As Xi Jinping meets Donald Trump in Washington, a temporary truce extension and narrow artificial intelligence talks will leave the fundamental US-China conflict entirely unchanged.
Interests first, capabilities second, statements last
The state visit is announced, and the capitals reach for their scripts. Chinese President Xi Jinping will visit the United States from September 23 to 25 for talks with US President Donald Trump, as confirmed by Beijing on Monday. Foreign ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun stated that the two leaders would have an in-depth exchange of views on major issues concerning China-US relations and world peace and development. Guo added that Beijing would work with the US to enrich the substance of the relationship of constructive strategic stability between China and the US. They would strengthen dialogue and cooperation, and properly manage differences. President Donald Trump told reporters aboard Air Force One on Sunday that he will be discussing almost everything with him. A US official confirmed that President Trump will personally welcome President Xi at Joint Base Andrews on Wednesday before their meetings on Thursday. But diplomacy is not built on airport arrivals. It is built on what nations want, what they can break, and what the bill looks like in five years.
Consider the baseline of power. The World Bank records China's annual GDP growth down, while the United States sits slowing. This describes two slowing giants locked in structural friction. Points of friction include Chinese access to advanced semiconductors, technology copying and transfer, and AI regulation, as reported by G1 Globo. The US has restricted Chinese access to high-end semiconductors and other strategic technologies. Meanwhile, China accuses Washington of attempting to limit its technological development. To understand this friction, look to the US-China trade war, where trade barriers are deployed as leverage to force structural changes in economic practices and technological transfer.
The mechanics of leverage in New York and Beijing
Before the principals shake hands in Washington, the workmen clear the floor. US and Chinese delegations held talks in New York on Sunday, focusing on artificial intelligence and trade, as noted by France 24. The talks were described as successful and constructive. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent met with Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng at JPMorgan Chase's New York headquarters, as reported by DW. He met alongside US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer and China's chief trade negotiator Li Chenggang, according to Al Jazeera. Bessent stated that the conversations were successful and agreed to meet again with He Lifeng. The delegations discussed creating a communication channel for AI concerns, according to Dawn. This US-China AI dialogue includes a proposed notification mechanism for AI-related incidents or instances that rise to a national security level.
Scott Bessent stated that moving from opaque to more transparency between the number one and the number two AI powers in the world is very important. Donald Trump observed that whoever wins in AI, wins. Yet Jamieson Greer stated that export controls on semiconductor manufacturing equipment and advanced AI chips were not included in the proposed AI mechanism, according to Al Jazeera. The talks also covered plans to operationalise a process to identify potential tariff cuts on goods via the Board of Trade. The trade truce is set to expire on November 10, according to the BBC. Jamieson Greer identified potential Chinese exports for lower tariffs as consumer and other low-tech goods. He identified US exports as medical devices, agricultural goods, and energy. But these prospective cuts run headlong into administrative reality. The U.S. Department of Commerce published a preliminary affirmative determination, finding that tin mill products from China are sold in the US at less than fair value. It slapped the China-wide entity with a weighted-average dumping margin of 136.52 percent and an adjusted cash deposit rate of 130.17 percent.
The illusion of breakthrough and the permanent friction
The argument for optimism rests on transactional rescue. Proponents of the summit claim that personal diplomacy between Donald Trump and Xi Jinping can avert a tariff collapse and establish guardrails for artificial intelligence. They rely on the working relationship between Scott Bessent and He Lifeng. They point to the May talks in Beijing, which concluded with an agreement for China to purchase Boeing jets and US agricultural goods in exchange for lower tariffs. They argue that both capitals have too much to lose from a sudden return to the punitive multi-digit tariff escalation seen previously. A temporary extension of the expiring November tariff truce is both logical and inevitable.
This optimistic case collapses against the long record of administrative protection and structural divergence. The 2020 Phase One Trade Agreement demonstrated that purchase targets fail when structural subsidies and macroeconomic pressures take over. China ultimately missed its purchase commitments during the pandemic slump. More importantly, while Bessent and He Lifeng discuss transparency in New York, the U.S. Department of Commerce issues triple-digit dumping penalties on tin mill products. The ITC continues antidumping duty orders on polyvinyl alcohol. This proves that the American trade enforcement machine operates independently of presidential summits. The proposed AI notification mechanism excludes semiconductor controls. Neither Washington nor Beijing is willing to yield technological dominance for the sake of a diplomatic communique. Just as Xi Jinping's 2015 state visit failed to resolve maritime and economic competition, this summit will leave the underlying trade war intact beneath a veneer of procedural de-escalation.
This summit will produce a temporary, face-saving extension of the expiring tariff truce. It will add a narrow, toothless communication channel for artificial intelligence incidents. The fundamental structure of the US-China technological and economic conflict remains entirely unchanged.
Sources
- Dawn: Chinese President Xi to visit US from Sept 23-25 for talks with Trump
- France 24: US, China discuss AI dialogue mechanism and trade ahead of Trump-XI summit
- G1 Globo: EUA e China tratam de negociações sobre comércio e IA antes de encontro entre Trump e Xi Jinping
- BBC: US and China discuss AI safety plan ahead of Trump-Xi summit
- Al Jazeera: US proposes AI safety notification mechanism in talks with China
- DW: US proposes AI safety mechanism in talks with China